Sivavakkiyam

44 / 524

Verse 44

  1. Siththameedhu, sindhaieedhu siivaneedhu! siththaree
  2. Saththieedhu? sambueedhu saadhipeedha atradhu
  3. Muththieedhu? muulameedhu muulaman thirangaleedhu?
  4. Viththillaadha viththilee idhinenadhenru iyambumee.
  1. Siththameedhu, sindhaieedhu siivaneedhu! siththaree
  2. Saththieedhu? sambueedhu saadhipeedha atradhu
  3. Muththieedhu? muulameedhu muulaman thirangaleedhu?
  4. Viththillaadha viththilee idhinenadhenru iyambumee.
Commentary

Siththargalin aanma saadhanai kalaichchorkalaiyum thaththuvak kattumaanangalaiyum kadandhu nirkum parama suuniya nilaiyai nokki ezhuppappadum vinaa. Siththam enpadhu edhu? Sindhai enpadhu edhu? Jiivaathmaa enpadhu edhu? Sakthi enrum sivan enrum peesidum pirivugal engee? Mukthi, muulaadhaaram, muulamandhirangal enpavai yaavum engee? Kaaranamum kaariyamum illaadha 'viththillaadha viththu' ennum aadhip paramborulin mauna veliyil ivai yaavum karaindhupoginrana. Angee 'idhu ennudaiyadhu, idhu unnudaiyadhu' enru edhanais sutta mudiyum? Anaiththuk karudhugolgalaiyum kadandha paraveliyee unmai enrunarththugiraar.

The siddhas are questioned as if their technical words were unpaid bills. What is mind, what is thought, what is the soul, what is power, what is Sambhu, what is liberation, what is the source, what are the root mantras? Into that list the verse sets one plain claim: the reality asked about is without division of caste. The place they must answer from is a seed that has no seed, and they are told to say, there, what this is. The vocabulary of attainment waits on that seedless seed.

The teaching

Sivavakkiyar aggressively deconstructs the esoteric jargon of scholastic Siddhas. What is intellect (Siththam)? What is thought (Sindhai)? What is the soul (Siivan)? What is power (Sakthi) or Shiva (Sambu)? What is liberation or root mantras? In the ultimate reality, all these conceptual categories and all caste divisions (Saadhipeedham) vanish. He demands that practitioners speak from the 'seedless seed' (Viththillaadha viththu)—the causeless primordial void prior to all mental formulations.

Verse 45 Odukka nilai

  1. Siththamatrus sindhaiyatrus siivanatru ninridam
  2. Saththiyatrus sambuvatrus saadhipeedha matrunal
  3. Muuththiyatru muulamatru muulamandhi rangalum
  4. Viththaiiththai iinraviththil vilaindhadhee sivaayamee.
  1. Siththamatrus sindhaiyatrus siivanatru ninridam
  2. Saththiyatrus sambuvatrus saadhipeedha matrunal
  3. Muuththiyatru muulamatru muulamandhi rangalum
  4. Viththaiiththai iinraviththil vilaindhadhee sivaayamee.
Commentary

Mundhaiya paadalin keelvigalukkup padhilaaga, thaththuvangal yaavum muulap paramborulil odungum 'layam' ennum odukka nilaiyai vilakkum unnadhap paadal. Siththam adangi, sindhanai oyndhu, thaniththa siiva unarvu karaiyum andha thuriyaadhiidha veliyil; sivasakthi peedhangalum, saadhi veerupaadugalum, mukthi patriya karpanaigalum, muulamandhirangalin sapthangalum yaavum atruppoginrana. Anaiththirkum viththaay vilangum andha aadhi muulap peruveliyil, anaiththu anda saraasarangalum 'sivaaya' ennum eegaththuva meyyoliyil mutrumuzhudhaaga odungip peerinpamaay nilaiperuginrana.

The questions just asked are answered by removal. A place stands with mind gone, thought gone, and soul gone; with power gone, Sambhu gone, and caste-division gone. Release, source, and the root mantras go too. The print's word here is Muuththi, beside the previous song's Muththi, and several line-ends are compressed, so the reading follows that list being cancelled. In the seed that brought this and that forth, what has been yielded up is Sivayam. Drawing inward is the reply the questions receive.

The teaching

The sublime state of cosmic dissolution (Odukka nilai / Laya). Here, the questions of the previous verse find their resolution through transcendental negation. It is the realm where intellect, conceptual thought, and individual soul-identity cease; where notions of Shakti and Sambhu dissolve; where all caste divisions, paths of liberation, and root mantras vanish. In that uncaused 'seed that birthed all seeds,' all existence effortlessly resolves into the primordial vibration: Sivayam.

Verse 46 Kiriyai

  1. Saadhiyaavadhu eedhadaa? salamdhiranda niirelaam
  2. Puudhavaasal onralo, puudhamaindhum onralo?
  3. Kaadhilvaalil, kaarai, kambi, paadagambon onralo?
  4. Saadhipeedham odhuginra thanmaienna thanmaiyo?
  1. Saadhiyaavadhu eedhadaa? salamdhiranda niirelaam
  2. Puudhavaasal onralo, puudhamaindhum onralo?
  3. Kaadhilvaalil, kaarai, kambi, paadagambon onralo?
  4. Saadhipeedham odhuginra thanmaienna thanmaiyo?
Commentary

Saadhip paagupaadugalaik sukkunuuraakkum miga unnadhamaana samaththuvath thaththuvap paadal. Saadhi enpadhu engee irukkiradhu? Anaiththu nadhigalilirundhum vazhindhu onruseerum niir verum thanniiree anri veeralla. Manidhargal anaivarum thaayin oree karuvarai vaasal vazhiyaagavee pirakkinranar; ellorudaiya udalum nilam, niir, thii, kaatru, aagaayam ennum aimbuudhangalaaleeyee aakkappattullana. Kaadhani, vaal, valaiyal, kaappu ena anigalangal palavaaga irundhaalum avai anaiththilum ulla thangam onree allavaa? Adippadai unmaiyee onraaga irukkaiyil, manidhargalaip pirappaal piriththus saadhi peedham peesuvadhu evvalavu periya madamai enru saattaiyadi kodukkiraar.

Caste is asked to identify itself. All water, once it has gathered, is water. The elements' doorway is one, and the five elements are one. A compressed list then sets ear, sword, karai, wire, and padaga-gold beside one another and asks whether they are one. Taken with the water and the elements, the list is many forms of a single stuff, though the printed items stay tight. The last line turns on the person who recites caste-difference and asks what sort of nature that nature is.

The teaching

Another fierce assault on the artificial cruelty of caste divisions (Kiriyai). Sivavakkiyar demands: What is caste? All water, once merged, is simply water. The entrance into physical existence through the womb is identical for all beings, and the five elements composing all human bodies are identical. Gold is one, whether fashioned into an earring, a sword-hilt, a bracelet, or an anklet. How then can human beings rationalize the grotesque absurdity of preaching caste superiority?

Verse 47 Arivu nilai

  1. Karandhapaal mulaippugaa, kadaindhavenney morpugaa;
  2. Udaindhupona sanginosai uyirgalum udarpugaa;
  3. Virindhapuu udhirndhagaayum miindupoy marambugaa;
  4. Irandhavar pirappadhillai illai illai illaiyee.
  1. Karandhapaal mulaippugaa, kadaindhavenney morpugaa;
  2. Udaindhupona sanginosai uyirgalum udarpugaa;
  3. Virindhapuu udhirndhagaayum miindupoy marambugaa;
  4. Irandhavar pirappadhillai illai illai illaiyee.
Commentary

Iyarkaiyin maaraadha vidhigalaiyum, udalin irudhi unmaiyaiyum vilakkum sivavaakkiyarin oppuyarvatra gnaanap paadal. Pasuvin madiyilirundhu karandha paal miindum madikkul pugaadhu; moraik kadaindhu eduththa venney miindum moraagaadhu; udaindhupona sangu miindum iniya osaiyai ezhuppaadhu; malarndha puuvum udhirndha kaayum miindum maraththin kilaiyil ottaadhu. Adheepola, pirindhupona uyir miindum adhee udalukkul pugundhu vaazhvadhillai; irandha manidhan miindum adhee pandha paasangalodu pirappadhillai. Indha udalin nilaiyaamaiyai unarndhu, azhivatra meyp paramborulai vaazhumbodhee adaivadhee aanma vidudhalaiyaagum.

Four pictures show what does not go back. Milk that was drawn does not return into the breast. Churned butter does not return into the buttermilk. The sound of a broken conch, and lives themselves, do not re-enter the body. An opened flower and a fallen fruit do not go back into the tree. The conclusion is as hard as the pictures. The dead are not born, and the line says there is not, three times. Irreversible things are stacked, and death is said to be like them.

The teaching

The absolute irreversibility of cosmic and biological law (Arivu nilai). Milk that has been milked cannot re-enter the udder; churned butter cannot dissolve back into buttermilk; the shattered music of a broken conch cannot be reconstituted; a departed soul cannot re-enter a dead corpse; a fallen blossom or ripe fruit cannot climb back onto the tree. With unsparing clarity, Sivavakkiyar shatters naive superstitious hopes of worldly resurrection or physical continuity: that which has died is gone forever; only the transcendent truth endures.

Verse 48

  1. Araiyinil kidandhapodhu anrudhuuymai enriliir,
  2. Thuraiarindhu niirguliththa anrudhuumai enriliir,
  3. Praiyarindhu niirpirandha anrudhuumai enriliir,
  4. Puraiilaadha iisarodu porundhumaaradhu engnganee.
  1. Araiyinil kidandhapodhu anrudhuuymai enriliir,
  2. Thuraiarindhu niirguliththa anrudhuumai enriliir,
  3. Praiyarindhu niirpirandha anrudhuumai enriliir,
  4. Puraiilaadha iisarodu porundhumaaradhu engnganee.
Commentary

Thiittu matrum maadhavidaayth thuuymai kuriththa samuugaththin polip paasaangugalai ambalappaduththum paadal. Thaayin irunda karuvaraikkul onpadhu maadhangal udhiraththodu udhiramaayk kidandhapodhu evarum ungalaith thiittu enru kuuravillaiyee! Palarum muuzhgi ezhum podhu aatruth thuraigalil kulikkumbodhu andha niiraith thiittu enru vilakkavillaiyee! Adheepola, ulaga uyirgal anaiththum udhiramum niirum thiranda muulap pirappin vazhiyee pirandhapodhu evarum thiittena odhungavillaiyee! Aanaal, iththagaiya iyarkaiyaana udaliyal niyadhigalukkup polik kattuppaadugalai vidhiththuvittu, kutramatra paramborulodu ungalaal eppadi irandarak kalakka mudiyum enru vinavugiraar.

Purity is shown as a word people use when the moment suits them. When it lay in the room, that day they did not say pure. The day they bathed at the ghat, knowing the bathing place, they did not say impure. The third line is compressed at its first word, printed with a pulled consonant, and on the day water came to be they likewise did not say impure. The verse then asks how anyone joins the lord who has no flaw.

The teaching

Sivavakkiyar exposes the hypocritical, opportunistic definitions of ritual purity and menstrual pollution (Thuumai). When the child lay in the mother's womb surrounded by bodily fluids, people did not declare it impure. When they plunge into the public river ghats to bathe, they do not consider the water polluted. On the day water was created, they did not call it impure. Yet they invent artificial taboos against natural processes while claiming to be fit to unite with the flawless, all-pervading Supreme Lord.

Verse 49

  1. Thuumai thuumai enrulee thuvandualaiyum eezhaigaal!
  2. Thuumaiyaana pennirukkath thuumaiponadhu evvidam?
  3. Aamaipola muzhugivandhu aneegaveedham odhuriir
  4. Thuumaiyum thirandurundu sorkurukkal aanadhee.
  1. Thuumai thuumai enrulee thuvandualaiyum eezhaigaal!
  2. Thuumaiyaana pennirukkath thuumaiponadhu evvidam?
  3. Aamaipola muzhugivandhu aneegaveedham odhuriir
  4. Thuumaiyum thirandurundu sorkurukkal aanadhee.
Commentary

Pengalin iyarkai nigazhvaana maadhavidaayaith 'thiittu' enru kuurip pengalai odhukkum aanaadhikkak kuruttu nambikkaigalais saadum puratsigarap paadal. 'Thiittu, thiittu' enru kuuchchalittu alaiginra ariviligalee! Thiittukkuriyaval enru niingal muththirai kuththum pen ungal kanmunnee nalamaaga irukkumbodhu, niingal karpanai seydha andhath thiittu engee senradhu? Kulaththu niiril aamaiyaip pola muuzhgi ezhundhu, udal thuuymai adaindhuvittadhaaga enni veedhangalai odhum poli veedadhaarigalee! Pirappai arulum thaayth thanmaiyai izhivaagap peesivittu, eettus suraikkaaygalaip podhikkum ungal sorkurukkalin ariyaamaiyee ulagileeyee thirandurunda unmaiyaana thiittaagum enru muzhangugiraar.

The poor are seen sagging and wandering inside the cry of impurity, impurity. The question that stops them is simple. While the woman they call impure is right there, where did the impurity go? It would have a place if the word were solid. Instead they dive like a tortoise, come up, and recite many Vedas. The last line gathers the impurity itself, rolled into a mass, and says it has become gurus made of words. The teachers of the rule are what the stain has rolled itself into.

The teaching

A scathing defense of women and condemnation of patriarchal taboos regarding menstrual pollution (Thuumai). Fools wander about obsessively shrieking about pollution and female impurity, yet when the woman herself stands right before them, where has this supposed 'impurity' gone? These same hypocrites dive into sacred ponds like tortoises, surface, and chant the Vedas, unaware that their dogmatic teachers and word-bound gurus are themselves the real congealed embodiment of spiritual pollution.